How Are You Monitored Downloading Torrents?

Torrenting can be convenient for file sharing, but it also leaves digital footprints that are easy to track. When you torrent, your IP address becomes publicly visible. Various entities monitor and collect this data, including ISPs, copyright holders, and data brokers. They usually use it for multiple purposes; some are legal, some less so.

Some companies take a step further and link these IP addresses to physical addresses, enabling more precise tracking. Additionally, certain unethical businesses monitor torrent activities to exploit legal grey areas.

While protecting intellectual property is a valid concern, some of these businesses employ aggressive tactics and take advantage of legal grey areas surrounding torrenting.

In this article, we’ll discuss how torrent users are tracked, who’s interested in your torrent activity, and how you can protect yourself.

The Ease of Identification: How are torrents tracked?

In the vast, interconnected landscape of the internet, it might seem like your activities would be hard to track. Yet, pinpointing user activity is surprisingly straightforward when it comes to torrenting. Let’s unpack the key methods that make such identification possible. As we explore these techniques, you’ll see that safeguarding your privacy requires understanding the methods used to compromise it.

Deep packet inspections

Deep packet inspection (DPI) is a sophisticated form of network packet filtering. In simple terms, it’s a method that allows to look closely at the data being sent over a specific network. While traditional packet filtering, or shallow packet inspection, only checks the “envelope” (the header of the packet), DPI goes a step further and “opens the envelope” to inspect the contents inside.

In the context of torrenting, DPI can be used to detect traffic by looking at the characteristics of the data packets. Torrent data have specific patterns, and DPI can spot these patterns even if the traffic is not explicitly labeled.

Who uses DPI?

Deep packet inspection, being a form of direct network monitoring, is primarily utilized by entities with direct control over a network.

The most common users of DPI are Internet Service Providers. They often employ DPI to manage network traffic, enforce data caps, or comply with legal requirements to curb the sharing of copyrighted material. Some ISPs might also use it for controversial practices, like throttling certain types of traffic, including torrents.

Beyond ISPs, network administrators in certain settings, such as corporations and educational institutions, may also utilize DPI. Administrators use it to enforce network policies and manage network resources. Sometimes, they use it to prevent downloading or sharing illegal content on their networks.

Limitations of DPI

While DPI is powerful, it isn’t infallible. For one, it struggles with encrypted traffic. Encryption can scramble the data inside the packets, making it difficult for DPI to identify the contents. Moreover, DPI requires considerable processing power. Because of this, ISPs can’t always inspect every single data packet in real time, especially on busy networks.

Surveillance of torrent swarms

Torrenting operates on a peer-to-peer (P2P) network where each participant, known as a “peer”, shares files with others. A group of peers sharing a specific file forms a torrent swarm. When you download a file via torrent, your client doesn’t connect to a single source. Instead, it downloads pieces of the file from multiple peers in the swarm. At the same time, it uploads those pieces to other peers.

This interconnected system, efficient for file sharing, is intrinsically open. Anyone who joins the swarm, including those with ulterior motives, can see the IP addresses of all other peers.

As illustrated in the image below, even a regular user like you can view the IP addresses of members of your swarm within your torrent client.

IP addresses visible in a BitTorrent client

These are the peers who, at that specific moment, share the file with you, either by downloading or uploading. Their visibility underlines how open and easily observable this system can be.”

How seeder and leecher roles influence visibility and tracking risk in torrent swarms

In our previous article explaining what seeders, leechers, and peers are, we discussed the different roles within a torrent swarm. Now, let’s understand how these roles impact user tracking.

When you’re a seeder, you have a complete copy of the file and actively upload it to others in the swarm. This means your IP address is constantly engaged in the swarm, making it visible for a longer duration.

On the other hand, leechers, who are still downloading the file, may only be part of the swarm for a shorter period. In particular, this applies to those leechers who cease their uploads, exiting the swarm right after their downloads are complete. However, during the time they are part of the swarm, their IP addresses are just as visible as those of the seeders.

Simply put, the more active you are in a swarm (either seeding or leeching), the more visible you become to anyone monitoring it. So, while torrenting relies on active participation for its efficiency, this very participation increases the risk of being tracked.

Real-world Demonstration of Torrent Monitoring

While understanding the technicalities of torrent tracking is essential, it’s also valuable to see this process in action in the real world. A few platforms provide insight into the scale of torrent monitoring. They offer a visual demonstration of how torrent activities are scrutinized.

As we look at the workings of a couple of public torrent monitoring sites, remember: these platforms are just the tip of the iceberg.

ScanEye 

ScanEye is a site that monitors public torrent activity. It lets users glimpse the torrent activity associated with their IP addresses. When you visit ScanEye, the site detects your IP address. Then, it shows a list of torrents downloaded using that same IP.

Each entry includes details such as the torrent’s name, the download date, and the file’s category (movies, music, software, etc.). It’s imperative to remember that ScanEye is not an exhaustive tracker. It only shows a small fraction of total torrent activity. Yet, its results remind us how easily someone can trace torrent downloads to an IP address.

IKnowWhatYouDownload

Another public site that monitors torrent activity is IKnowWhatYouDownload. This platform goes a step further than ScanEye. It maintains an extensive database that logs many IP addresses and their associated torrent downloads each day.

IKnowWhatYouDownload’s monitoring scale can provide a better sense of how multiple torrent users are being tracked at any given time. It may not represent all torrent activity worldwide. But the sheer volume of data it collects daily is a testament to the widespread and ongoing nature of torrent monitoring.

A Clear IP is Not a Guarantee of Privacy

Using platforms like ScanEye and IKnowWhatYouDownload can indeed provide a glimpse into your torrenting activity linked to your IP. However, it’s essential to remember that these are just two among many monitoring entities. Not finding your IP address listed on these sites doesn’t necessarily mean you’re flying under the radar.

There are countless other tracking entities, some of which maintain much more extensive and detailed databases. So, a clear result on these sites doesn’t guarantee that your torrenting activity is going unnoticed. This reinforces the importance of adopting robust measures to protect your privacy while torrenting.

The Scope and Seriousness of Torrent Monitoring: Stats and Case Studies

Torrent monitoring is not just a theoretical concern. Numerous lawsuits, high-profile incidents, and impressive usage stats demonstrate this reality. The involvement of high-profile companies like MarkMonitor and Rightscorp, which provide services to track torrent swarms, highlights the seriousness of this matter.

Copyright holders have frequently taken legal actions against torrent users. An infamous example is the 2010 lawsuit by the U.S. Copyright Group against approximately 5,000 individuals. They allegedly downloaded and shared the movie “The Hurt Locker”. 

The Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) and the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) have also been notably active. For instance, in 2012, the RIAA won a lawsuit against a Minnesota woman for sharing 24 songs, leading to a hefty fine of $222,000.

High-profile torrent site seizures

Many high-profile seizures of torrent sites have taken place over the years. Perhaps the most infamous is the 2014 shutdown of The Pirate Bay by Swedish police. As you may have noticed back then, this event alone caused a significant drop in overall torrent traffic.

Usage statistics

Despite the risks, torrenting remains a popular method of sharing files. According to a Sandvine report in 2018, BitTorrent accounted for 22% of upstream and almost 3% of downstream traffic.

The Observers: Who’s Watching Your Torrent Activity?

Understanding how torrent users are tracked is one aspect of the equation. But who are the observers monitoring torrent activity? Several entities are interested in keeping a close watch on torrent users, each with their unique reasons. 

Let’s explore the identities behind these prying eyes in the torrenting world. From ISPs to copyright trolls, we’ll unravel why these entities care about your torrent activity.

Internet Service Providers (ISPs): The gatekeepers of your online activity

ISPs play a central role in connecting you to the internet, making them an integral part of the torrent tracking landscape. As gatekeepers of your online traffic, they can see and monitor the data you send and receive, including torrenting activities.

ISPs have various reasons for keeping tabs on torrent activity. One reason is to manage network traffic. Torrenting often involves downloading and uploading large files, which consume significant bandwidth. If many users torrent simultaneously, it could lead to network congestion.

Moreover, ISPs can face legal pressure from copyright holders or regulatory bodies to curb the sharing of copyrighted content on their networks. Therefore, ISPs might monitor torrent traffic to mitigate legal risks.

How do ISPs monitor torrent activity?

As your internet gateway, ISPs can utilize tools such as Deep Packet Inspection (DPI) to analyze the data packets you send and receive.

An ISP using DPI to detect torrenting activity

Through this process, they can detect patterns characteristic of torrent traffic. When a user downloads or shares files via torrent, the ISP can identify this activity based on these unique patterns.

Copyright holders have a vested interest in preventing the unauthorized sharing of their content. These include movie studios, record labels, software developers, and book publishers. Their primary concern is protecting their intellectual property.

The reasons for copyright holders’ vigilance are clear: torrenting can lead to significant financial losses. Every unauthorized download potentially represents a lost sale. Furthermore, the widespread availability of their content on torrent platforms can devalue their work and dilute their control over it.

Copyright holders rely on swarm monitoring to track torrent activity to combat this issue. Some do the work themselves by acting as peers in a torrent swarm. That allows them to see the IP addresses of other peers sharing their content. 

However, most of them employ companies that specialize in monitoring BitTorrent swarms. These firms can track specific torrent files and trace them back to the IP addresses used to share them.

Armed with this information, they can take legal action against those they suspect are infringing on their copyrights.

Copyright trolls are typically law firms or small companies that acquire rights to certain copyrighted materials. Their sole aim is to legally pursue alleged infringers rather than producing or distributing the content.

Their modus operandi often involves a scheme that many consider “legal bullying”. They track down torrent users sharing their assigned copyrighted content, issue legal threats, and demand settlements, usually amounting to a few thousand dollars. 

Some even strategically ensure their copyrighted works are easily discoverable on torrent sites. The goal is to bait potential infringers, increasing their chances of issuing settlements.

Similar to rightsholders, copyright trolls use swarm monitoring to track torrent activity. They monitor specific torrent files known to contain the copyrighted material they have rights to. After that, they identify the IP addresses involved in the sharing process.

Once they have the IP addresses, they can request that the associated ISP reveal the user’s identity. They can then target these individuals with legal threats and demands for a settlement, turning torrent tracking into a profit-making scheme.

Data Brokers: The silent observers of the torrent ecosystem

In the torrent ecosystem, data brokers are often behind-the-scenes entities. These companies collect, analyze, and sell information related to various online activities, including torrenting. The sale of this valuable information makes data brokerage a lucrative operation.

Who is interested in buying data brokers’ information?

  • Copyright Holders and Legal Entities: They may use this information to identify and pursue alleged copyright infringers.
  • Marketing and Advertising Companies: This data can help these firms understand consumer behavior, interests, and trends.
  • Cybersecurity Firms: Torrenting data can contribute to broader cybersecurity investigations or threat evaluations.
  • Research Institutions: Academics and researchers could find this data valuable for studies on online behavior, digital piracy, or related fields.

How do data brokers monitor torrent activity?

Data brokers typically don’t monitor torrents directly. Instead, they gather vast amounts of data from diverse sources. These include ISPs, websites, social media platforms, and other data-collecting services. This comprehensive pool of information enables them to create detailed profiles of internet users, including their torrenting habits.

They can often provide a complete view of a user’s torrenting activity, making it a valuable asset to sell to interested parties.

Safeguarding Your Privacy: A Necessity in Today’s Digital World

In the face of such extensive tracking and monitoring, privacy has become a pressing issue for torrent users. It’s vital to understand that while torrenting itself isn’t illegal, sharing copyrighted materials without permission is. Sometimes, that can happen accidentally when the user does not know he’s downloading a protected file. Therefore, maintaining privacy can help ensure that your online activities aren’t misconstrued or used against you.

VPNs and proxy servers: tools for privacy

Virtual Private Networks and Proxy Servers can obscure your online activities, including torrenting, from prying eyes. These tools work in somewhat similar ways. Essentially, they serve as intermediaries between your computer and the internet, handling data requests on your behalf. This arrangement hides your IP address, making your online activities and downloads harder to track.

While both tools provide privacy, a VPN has advantages over a proxy server. In a few words, it has the advantage of encrypting your data.

These are some torrent-friendly VPNs we recommend:

RISING STAR
Surfshark
Surfshark
  • Supports P2P downloads
  • Good set of features
  • Unlimited connections
EDITOR'S PICK
NordVPN
NordVPN
  • Optimized for torrenting
  • Vast P2P server network
  • Top VPN choice for P2P
BUDGET PICK
PureVPN
PureVPN
  • Robust torrent features
  • Optimized P2P servers
  • Excellent value for money

Conclusion: Staying Ahead in a World of Constant Monitoring

The torrent ecosystem is far more intricate and monitored than many realize. From your ISP to data brokers, various entities are watching torrent activity. Each of these players has their own motives. However, the implications for torrent users are the same: your downloads are not as private as you might think.

Deep packet inspections and surveillance of torrent swarms are good examples of tools that contribute to tracking torrent activity. Recognizing these realities is the first step to protecting your privacy. 

While torrenting might seem like a game of cat and mouse, you can tilt the balance in your favor with the right tools and awareness.